The Relevance of David Reimer to Transsexuals
During the late 20th century, a medical scandal took place, wherein XY males without Disorders of Sexual Development were surgically reassigned female. The most famous of these cases is David Reimer, who was erroneously reported as a "successful" case by John Money, until Milton Diamond and John Colapinto later revealed he had refused to be reassigned female. In the end, Reimer tragically committed suicide. There are harrowing parallels between this scandal and the modern scandal of "transgender children" (child sex changes). However, conservative media has taken it a step further by comparing it to the transition of adults. Does David Reimer prove that transsexuality is a sham? Nature vs. Nurture : Revisited To make sense these debates, one must contrast three theories about sex (male or female) and gender (masculine or feminine) when it comes to the sexual differentiation of the brain: Conservative: Although they do not believe in "gender", conservat...